Chapter 2
Julian bolted the steel-reinforced door behind them, throwing two deadbolts and dropping a rusted steel bar into place.
The back office smelled of stale Folgers, brake fluid, and the sour reek of Julian’s sweat. The four of them stood in the narrow space between a dented metal filing cabinet and an oil-stained desk, nobody sitting down.
"Show me," Julian demanded, his bloodshot eyes fixed on Evan’s hands. "Show me the plastic."
Evan pulled the amber shard from his pocket and set it on the glass desk blotter.
Julian picked it up with calloused, oil-blackened fingers. He brought it close to his face under the bare desk lamp, turning it over and over. His breath began to hitch. "This... this is from the right front assembly. The Sunfire had a reproduction housing from an aftermarket shop in Canton. The OEM code was clipped on the bottom flange." His thumb scraped against the edge. "This is the piece that broke when we dragged it into the tree line."
"How?" Marcus asked, his voice climbing an octave, losing every ounce of its practiced political poise. He grabbed the back of the metal office chair, his knuckles turning white. "How can that exist, Julian? You told us you torched every single bolt! You told us the entire body was liquefied!"
"It was!" Julian snarled, lunging forward until he was inches from Marcus’s face, spittle flying from his lips. "I crushed it, Marcus! You were too busy puking your guts out in the bushes to watch, but I did the dirty work! I fed it through the press twice! I watched the roof touch the floorboards!"
"Then explain that!" Marcus pointed a shaking finger at the shard. "Explain how someone drove it onto Evan’s driveway tonight!"
"Nobody drove *that* car," Seth said quietly, his voice hollow. He stood near the door, his massive frame blocking the only exit, his arms crossed tightly across his chest as if trying to hold his ribs together. "It’s an intimidation tactic. Somebody found out. Somebody bought another 1999 Sunfire, put the same tires on it, and drove it up the hill to rattle us."
"Who?" Evan’s voice cut through the room like a scalpel. He stood motionless, his cashmere coat still damp, his gaze cold and calculating. "Who in Newford knows enough about a dead runaway hitchhiker from ten years ago to track down the exact tire specs and an amber housing from Canton?"
No one answered. The only sound was the steady, relentless hammer of rain against the sheet-metal ceiling.
"Leo Wright didn't have anyone," Seth whispered, staring at the floor. "He was seventeen. He had a foster file three inches thick. He had run away from three group homes in Columbus before he ended up walking down Route 9 in the dark. The state closed the case inside six months. They assumed he took a freight train to Chicago or overdosed in a flophouse."
"He had an uncle," Marcus said suddenly, his eyes darting toward the frosted office window.
Evan turned his head slowly. "What did you say?"
"He had an uncle," Marcus repeated, swallowing hard. "I found out during my first council campaign five years ago when I had access to the old township zoning and custody archives. Some distant maternal relation who lived out near the reservoir. But the guy never filed a claim. He never showed up to town meetings. Nobody ever looked for the boy."
"If somebody is looking now," Julian said, his hand twitching toward the revolver on the desk, "we find them. We put them in the swamp next to the boy."
"Are you insane?" Marcus gasped, taking a step back, knocking against the metal filing cabinet with a loud clang. "Are you out of your goddamned mind, Julian? We’re not nineteen-year-old drunks anymore! Look at us! I'm running for mayor in November! Evan is developing the entire north waterfront! Seth is about to be named district superintendent! We can’t just... we can’t start killing people!"
"Then what do you propose, Councilman?" Evan said, his tone chillingly mild. "You want to invite them to tea? You want to write them a check from your campaign account?"
"We go to the Sheriff," Marcus blurted out.
The room went dead.
Even the rain seemed to fade behind the sudden, suffocating pressure in the air.
Julian let out a dry, barking laugh that sounded like an engine backfiring. Seth looked up, his jaw slack with disbelief.
"Say that again," Evan whispered.
"Listen to me!" Marcus cried, raising both hands defensively, sweat glistening on his forehead under the harsh fluorescent tube. "Listen to the logic! We are the victims of an extortion plot! If someone is stalking Evan, trespassing on private property, leaving threatening tokens—that is a felony! We go to Sheriff Miller. We tell him Evan is being harassed by a disgruntled contractor or a political rival. We don’t mention Leo! We just report the vehicle, we let the county deputies put up road checkpoints, we let them pull over every red Pontiac in three counties! We use the law to protect us without ever telling them what happened ten years ago!"
Evan walked across the narrow office. He didn't rush. His steps were measured, quiet, his loafers making no sound on the grease-caked linoleum. He stopped two inches from Marcus’s chest.
He didn't yell. He leaned in, his voice dropping into a razor-thin murmur that made Marcus flinch.
"You think Ronald Miller is an idiot, Marcus?" Evan asked. "You think the county sheriff’s department is going to set up roadblocks for a set of tire ruts without running a full canvas? The moment a deputy starts asking questions about a red 1999 Sunfire, some clerk in records is going to flag the open missing persons docket from October 2014."
"They won't connect it—"
"They will connect you, you fool!" Evan shoved Marcus back, hard enough that the councilman’s spine slammed against the filing cabinet. "The boy didn't disappear into thin air! His bones are wrapped in two layers of plastic sheeting inside the drainage culvert beneath the old Erie freight line! If the state police get involved, they don't look for a trespasser. They bring ground-penetrating radar. They bring forensic teams from Columbus. And when they dig up that culvert, they find the watch Seth dropped. They find the zip ties Julian took from this very garage. And then we don't worry about your mayoral campaign, Marcus. We worry about thirty years to life in Mansfield Correctional for aggravated vehicular homicide and tampering with a corpse."
Marcus slid down an inch against the metal cabinet, his breath coming in shallow, shuddering gasps. The polished veneer of the politician was entirely gone, replaced by the terrified boy who had stood in the headlights ten years ago, crying while Julian fetched the tow straps.
"Our silence is the only reason we are breathing free air," Evan said, his voice ruthless and steady, surveying the other three men. "For ten years, we have had one rule. One absolute commandment. We do not call the authorities. We do not involve police. We do not whisper the name Leo Wright to our wives, our priests, or our lawyers. The moment a badge gets within ten feet of this, the house falls. All of it."
On iPhone, notifications need PulpTale on your Home Screen:
1. Tap the Share button in Safari, then "Add to Home Screen".
2. Open PulpTale from your Home Screen and we'll ask again.
