Chapter 2
"You're still breathing that mold, Investigator," she said. Her voice was flat, dried out by decades of carbon paper and legal dust.
"Mold doesn't bite, Mrs. Cleary."
"It does if you stay down here past five. The furnace kicks on at five-fifteen. Smells like sulfur and rat droppings." She stepped off the bottom riser, her rubber-tipped cane sinking slightly into the soft, rotting linoleum near the drain. She set the thermos on the corner of his table. "Brought you hot water. There’s instant Folgers in the jar by the water heater if your stomach can take it."
"I appreciate it."
She didn't leave. She stood there, her small hands clasped over the crook of her cane, looking not at Wesley, but at the cardboard box with *CASE 98-07-14B* scrawled on its side. Her knuckles were enlarged with arthritis, the skin translucent, showing the blue roadmap of her veins.
"You won't find anything in that box that Calloway didn't want the state to read twenty-six years ago," she said quietly.
"Calloway was thorough," Wesley said, keeping his tone light, conversational. The tone he used on county supervisors before he served them with grand jury subpoenas. "He wrote three pages on the boot prints in the mud. Described the lug pattern down to the millimeter. Said it was a work boot, Sears DieHard, size eleven, worn down at the outside heel."
Martha’s mouth twitched, a minuscule tuck at the left corner. "Calloway had an eye for tracks. His daddy was a timber scout."
"He also wrote that the killer was likely a rail-rider. An itinerant." Wesley picked up his pen, clicking it once. *Click. Clack.* "Did you have a lot of rail-riders coming through Black River in '98, Mrs. Cleary? Dropping off the Norfolk Southern line, walking four miles inland through a tropical depression just to beat a Columbus boy to death with a timber hook in an old mill?"
Martha’s gaze didn't waver from the box. "It was a wild night, Investigator. People forget how dark it gets out by the river when the clouds drop below the ridges. You can't see your own hand two inches off your nose. A man out there alone, stranded... anything could have come out of the timber."
"Anything," Wesley repeated. "Or anyone."
"The world’s full of mean men who don't have addresses," she said. The phrase was smooth, rounded by decades of use. It sounded less like an opinion and more like something the town had recited over lard-crust pies and funeral casseroles until the words had the hardness of river pebbles. "Julian Vance was an unfortunate boy. His mother came down here from Columbus to collect his trunk. Calloway put her up at the Riverview Inn, paid for her gas home out of the benevolent fund. He was good to her."
"Did Calloway let her see the coroner's file?"
"She was a Christian woman," Martha said, her voice dropping a fraction of a degree, sharpening into something thin and defensive. "She didn't need to see what iron does to meat. No mother needs that."
"No," Wesley agreed softly. "She didn't. But the State of Ohio did. And so does the Attorney General's office."
Martha turned her eyes on him then. They were sharp, clear, and utterly devoid of fear. There was only a profound, stubborn weariness in them, the look of an old guard dog standing across a threshold it had held for a lifetime.
"The Attorney General sits in an air-conditioned office in the capital," she said. "He don't know what it takes to keep sixty families from tearing each other’s throats out when the river gets into the well water. Calloway did. Black River was whole when he took the star, and it was whole when he laid it down."
"Julian Vance wasn't whole," Wesley said.
Martha didn't answer. She took two steps back toward the wooden stairs, her cane thumping against the floorboards. "Leave the light off when you pull the door. The switch sticks, and if the bulb stays on all night, it trips the breaker for the probate office."
She climbed three stairs, paused, and looked back through the banister rails. Her face was cut in half by the shadow of the staircase stringer.
"You're wasting your time looking for a monster with an address, Mr. Ross," she whispered. "The man who killed Julian Vance didn't have a house in this valley. He never did."
She didn't wait for his reply. The door clicked shut at the top of the stairs, and the sound of the deadbolt sliding into place echoed through the cellar like a rimfire cartridge dropping on concrete.
Wesley stood up. He didn't turn on the Folgers water.
He walked over to the bank of green metal filing cabinets along the back wall—the ones marked *SHERIFF'S DEPT - ROSTER & PAYROLL: 1990–2000*.
He knew how these towns worked. He had seen the pattern in Adams County, in Meigs, in Scioto. A violent crime happens in the dark. A body is found. If it was an outsider—a drifter, a migrant, a petty thief—the local law hung it around their neck within forty-eight hours, dragged them through the district court, and took their pictures for the *Black River Gazette*.
You only hid the body in an open file if the killer was someone you couldn't put in an orange jumpsuit without bringing the whole courthouse down.
Wesley pulled open the drawer for 1998.
He flipped past the carbon pay slips until he reached July.
On July 14, 1998, the Black River County Sheriff’s Department had seven full-time road deputies, three dispatchers, and two jailers.
Wesley pulled out his yellow pad and cross-referenced the names against the incident roster from that night.
Deputy Dale Higgins: *Dispatched to low-water bridge on County 12 at 2215. Road washout.* Deputy Marcus Vance (no relation to victim): *Patrol duty, southern sector. Cleared at 0300.* Deputy Wayne Thorne: *On leave.*
Wesley tapped his pen against Wayne Thorne’s name.
He pulled Thorne’s personnel jacket. Wayne Thorne had been twenty-six years old in the summer of 1998. His father, Big Earl Thorne, owned the Black River Gravel & Stone quarry and had served as county commissioner for fourteen years before dying of a stroke on a bass boat in Kentucky.
According to the disciplinary sheets tucked into the rear of the folder, Wayne Thorne had been suspended twice in 1997: once for breaking a prisoner’s jaw during a DUI processing in the sally port, and once for firing three rounds from his service weapon through the ceiling of the Black River Tavern while off-duty.
Both suspensions had been overturned by Sheriff Calloway Miller "for lack of corroborating witness testimony."
Wesley flipped through the payroll records. On July 13, 1998, Wayne Thorne had been put on two weeks of paid administrative leave for an unspecified "medical condition." On July 16—two days after Julian Vance’s head was smashed into a sawdust hopper—Wayne Thorne had resigned from the department, citing a desire to pursue "private enterprise opportunities in the aggregate hauling industry."
Three months later, Thorne had moved to Mobile, Alabama.
Wesley looked back at the table, where the yellow legal pad lay over the redacted autopsy.
*One man,* Wesley thought. His pulse picked up, that steady, cold rhythm that always arrived when the pieces of an old lie began to show their seams. *A high-strung, violent deputy with a commissioner for a father and an iron-fisted sheriff looking out for the family name.*
On iPhone, notifications need PulpTale on your Home Screen:
1. Tap the Share button in Safari, then "Add to Home Screen".
2. Open PulpTale from your Home Screen and we'll ask again.
